MG5 EV vs Tesla Model Y: two approaches to an electric car

Electric cars have long ceased to be exotic, and the choice now comes down not to "whether to buy or not", but to "which one". The MG5 EV and Tesla Model Y seem to be from different worlds, but they often end up on the same buyer's list. One relies on simplicity and practicality, the other on technology and drive. In this article, we will see how they really differ in everyday life, without exaggeration and loud promises.

We remind you that you can purchase home and commercial charging stations in our online storeand also use the public charging stations ECOFACTORcharging points located throughout Ukraine. For convenient access to charging infrastructure, we recommend using our mobile applicationwhich is available on iOS and Android.

Format and positioning of models

MG5 EV: the practical electric all-rounder

The MG5 EV is built as a classic middle-class wagon. Its strength is not in its novelty effect, but in its rationality.

The main features of the format:

• Station Wagon body with a focus on luggage and everyday tasks;
• more compact dimensions and a lower stance;
• focus on urban and regional travel;
• easy operation without complex adaptation;

This is a car that is well suited to those who want to switch to electric traction without changing their lifestyle.

Tesla Model Y: a versatile electric crossover

Model Y is immediately positioned as a more versatile solution. A higher body, larger dimensions and a different philosophy of use.

What defines the Model Y format:

• SUV body with plenty of space;
• higher ride height and a sense of control over the road;
• focus on long journeys and the highway;
• Tight integration of technology and software;

This is the choice for those who want not just an electric car, but a platform with a lot of possibilities.

Battery, range and efficiency

What you need to know about the MG5 EV

The MG5 EV Standard Range is equipped with a battery with a useful capacity of 46 kWh. In real-world use, the car demonstrates a calm and predictable character.

Key points:

• a real range of about 265 km on average;
• in the city, in mild weather, the range is up to 400 km;
• In winter, the range can be reduced to ~190 km on the highway;
• average energy consumption of about 174 Wh/km;

The MG5 EV is well suited for regular routes where predictability is more important than maximum performance.

How the Tesla Model Y behaves

The Tesla Model Y Standard RWD has a larger 60 kWh battery pack and significantly better energy efficiency.

Features:

• real mixed range of about 380 km;
• In the city, under favourable conditions, performance over 500 km is possible;
• on the track, even in winter, the reserve remains relatively stable;
• average energy consumption of about 158 Wh/km;

Thanks to the heat pump and software optimisation, the Model Y is better suited for long journeys.

Charging and long-distance routes

MG5 EV: unhurried but clear

The MG5 EV is not designed for aggressive charging scenarios, but it works well in daily use.

Basic charging parameters:

• AC charging up to 11 kW;
• DC charging up to 63 kW;
• charge the 10-80% in approximately 38 minutes;
• V2L support up to 2.2 kW;

For most owners, this means charging at home or making scheduled stops on the road.

Tesla Model Y: speed as part of the philosophy

The Model Y was clearly designed with a fast infrastructure in mind.

Key features:

• AC charging up to 11 kW;
• DC charging up to 175 kW;
• charge the 10-80% in approximately 24 minutes;
• automatic battery heating before fast charging;

This gives you a significant advantage on the highway and in long-distance travel.

ECOFACTOR - the charging infrastructure for sustainable daily operation

This is where ECOFACTOR plays an important role, because in practice the difference between electric vehicles often comes down not to performance but to how easy and predictable they are to charge on a daily basis. We work with the charging infrastructure in a comprehensive manner and do not consider it as a separate element. For us, it is part of the actual use of an electric vehicle, where it is not the maximum power in numbers that matters, but stability and clear scenarios.

We design, develop and manufacture AC and DC power supplies charging stations with a capacity of up to 420 kW. All solutions are made in Ukraine and comply with industry standards. This makes it equally comfortable to charge both the MG5 EV, which feels good during scheduled stops and home charging, and the Tesla Model Y, for which fast DC charging often becomes part of long-distance travel. The versatility of the infrastructure actually levels the difference between the cars and gives you the freedom to choose your own style of use, rather than forcing you to adapt to restrictions.

In addition to the stations, we are developing online shop for electric vehicles. There you can choose chargers, cables and adaptersRFID cards and accessories for everyday use. It's the little things that make everyday use of an electric car so much easier, whether it's a relaxed city rhythm in the MG5 EV or an active trip in the Tesla Model Y.

For operators, we support a charging network management platform that allows them to monitor stations, set tariffs, analyse energy consumption and scale the network without complex technical processes. And for drivers, we have a mobile application on iOS and Android з interactive map of charging stations  is available all over Ukraine. It makes it easy to find the nearest points, manage charging and plan routes. As a result, infrastructure ceases to be a limitation and becomes the backdrop against which different electric vehicles unfold at their own pace.

Dynamics and nature of movement

MG5 EV on the move

The MG5 EV is equipped with a 130 kW (177 hp) electric motor and front-wheel drive.

Impressions from the ride:

• 0-100 km/h acceleration in 7.7 seconds;
• smooth and calm pedal response;
• comfortable suspension for the city;
• Predictable behaviour on slippery surfaces;

This is a car that does not provoke, but calms you down.

Tesla Model Y on the move

The Tesla Model Y has an output of about 220 kW (299 hp) and rear-wheel drive.

What it feels like to drive:

• 0-100 km/h acceleration in 7.2 seconds;
• instant response to the accelerator;
• Stability at high speeds;
• a significant amount of traction in any situation;

Even in the base version, the Model Y feels more dynamic.

Practicality and space

MG5 EV: the shape works to your advantage

The MG5 EV offers:

• luggage compartment 479 litres as standard
• Up to 1367 litres with seats folded down
• flat floor and low loading threshold

The station wagon is convenient for large and non-standard items.

Tesla Model Y: space in all directions

Model Y takes on scale:

• boot 835 litres
• up to 2118 litres with seats folded down
• additional front luggage compartment with a capacity of 117 litres

This is the best option for travelling and family use with different luggage.

Which one is suitable for whom

The choice between the MG5 EV and the Tesla Model Y rarely comes down to dry numbers or technical tables. Much more often, it comes down to lifestyle, daily routines and how the car should fit into the routine.

MG5 EV is suitable if

This car is a logical choice for those who perceive an electric car as practical transport, not a technological experiment.

The MG5 EV will work well if:

• You need an electric car for daily commuting without drastic changes in habits;
• The versatile body and convenient luggage compartment for everyday tasks are important;
• routes are mainly urban or intercity for moderate distances;
• charging most often takes place at home or at familiar locations;
• Predictability, simple control logic and a minimum of digital "surprises" are valued;

The MG5 EV is typically chosen by those who want to use an electric car in peace and not think about it more than necessary every day.

Tesla Model Y is suitable if

The Model Y is more focused on an active rhythm and a variety of use cases.

Tesla Model Y is a logical choice if:

• Dynamics, power reserve and confidence on the track are important
• long journeys with quick stops for charging are common
• like the digital interface and regular software updates
• You want to have a reserve of opportunities "for the future", not just for today
• there is access to fast DC charging infrastructure or it is being actively developed

The Model Y is usually chosen by those who want to feel an electric car as part of the technological space, not just a means of transport.

As a result, the MG5 EV is more about calm and logic, while the Tesla Model Y is about pace and flexibility. And it is this distinction that best explains why both models find their audience, even when competing with each other.

Conclusion.

Comparing the MG5 EV and Tesla Model Y ultimately comes down to neither tables nor figures in the specifications. It's about the approach. The MG5 EV looks like an honest and down-to-earth option for those who want an electric car without too much stress. It doesn't force you to change your habits, doesn't require constant attention to the interface, and fits well into your daily rhythm. It's a car that just does its job and does it quietly.

Tesla Model Y offers a different attitude. It's more about the range of possibilities, technology and readiness for different scenarios. It's faster, more flexible and better suited for active journeys and highways. But with this comes the need to adapt both the interface and the style of use.

None of the models is universally better. They simply meet different expectations. If simplicity, practicality and predictability are important, the MG5 EV makes perfect sense. If you want dynamics, technology, and a sense of forward motion, the Model Y gives you exactly that. There is no wrong choice in this comparison, only the one that is best for you.

Questions and answers